By Richard Davis
We would probably agree that we stand to learn more from our setbacks than from what goes well. Wow, it can be painful though!
I returned from a two year OD assignment with an NGO in Cambodia, which until the final fortnight I would have judged an almost blemish-free success. Unfortunately, in the final days one of the changes my client and I had been pursuing blew up in our faces. And yet as I look back, the writing was on the wall:
By Stanley Arumugam
I did not feel like getting involved again with this team. Our initial session was intense, almost toxic, though we made some progress. When they requested follow-up, I was not sure. Some were obviously committed to working things out, but the other camp was resisting at every turn. In the middle of a full load of work, spending the afternoon with this team was not appealing, but I accepted, rather reluctantly.
We started with review and reflection of the journey to date, but as soon as we did our round robin, the ‘dissenting’ team member let fly with a monologue that stopped everyone in their tracks. She asked if it was useful to even address unresolved issues and what that would do for the team.
We then discussed whether the team was up for exploring these difficult issues again. It felt important to hear out the dissenter who’s perspectives usually questioned/opposed other team members. At the end of an initially awkward conversation the team agreed the need to revisit the tough, difficult issues – even though it felt like going into a painful past. How the conversation took place was really important. In a safe, guided way the team was able to surface issues that were still under the water. Things that would have been lost if we just wanted to move on.
This was only possible because we chose to listen to the dissenting voice. Despite the team’s initial desire to keep the positive momentum, avoid further anxiety and move on, the dissenting voice forced us to slow down. It turned out to be a gift as we got to grips with heartfelt issues. As a facilitator I learned a powerful lesson in holding space for a dissenting team member. It did not result in stuckness, but in significant progress.
- Which dissenting voices do you need to listen to?
- Where do you need to allow deep and maybe heated discussions to take place?
By Tobias Nyondo
There are always undiscussable issues in any organization. There are usually ‘elephants in the room’. We shy away from naming them. We steer clear of brutal facts. It would seem disloyal to bring them up. We fear if we bring up such issues, we will be labelled a rebel and may even face reprisals.
I was asked to facilitate two meetings of over 250 leaders from my church. Rather than dodge the big issues, I believed it was vital to put them on the table – even to the point of addressing the taboo subject of succession from the founding pastor (in his presence). This was not easy. I think it only worked because I managed to:
- Get the top leadership on my side – If you do not get visible support from the leadership, they will be a strong resistance and render the whole task useless.
- Create an atmosphere of liberty – People will only open up in a ‘safe space’ when there is a spirit of freedom in the place. “I felt the leadership wanted to hear this and did not feel I would be penalized”, one excited leader commented after the meeting.
- Use Diplomatic Honesty – Jesus certainly did not shy away from speaking the truth. But he always did it with grace and compassion.
- Ask the right questions – Framing the right questions around issues that often remain undiscussed requires discernment and wisdom (and even bouncing off leaders in advance).
Some of the questions that worked those days for me were:
- What would you do differently?
- What are the game changers here?
- What prohibits us from progressing forward?
- In which work situations do we need to discuss the undiscussables?
- What questions might energise change in these situations?
By Clinton Dix
I was recently leading a session on cross-cultural leadership with 25 mission agency staff from Brazil. As I spoke about the potential pitfalls and methods of preventing cultural mistakes, the chairman of the board whispered me a question, “Can I share with the group the email that you sent the board earlier this year?”
I stopped and quickly considered it. I had sent an email a while back carefully explaining our consulting requirements. It turned out that people reading my email completely misunderstood my intentions. So I agreed (slightly reluctantly). To my surprise the chairman had a copy of my email with him and proceeded to read it out, but without mentioning any names. The entire group howled with laughter that a mission leader could have sent such an email.
After the laughter died down I dared to admit: “I was the one that sent the email.” Stunned silence… I continued facilitating. From that moment on our discussions got deeper and more open.
I thought about this afterwards. Why had I dared to be vulnerable? I realised that it was only because we had worked together before and we trusted each other. What difference had it made? I also realised that after the “confession” the trust level deepened and our discussions also deepened. Research backs up both observations:
- Vulnerability and transparency are stronger when trust already exists.
- Vulnerability and transparency can deepen trust.
But…what about when there is no trust, either because something has occurred to break trust, or where there is no history to establish trust?
- Are we willing to be vulnerable, to be transparent in those situations?
- What stories can we share with others that allows us to be vulnerable, that can create that first spark of trust?
By Doreen Kwarimpa-Atim
I sometimes struggle with working with humility and confidence. I was making some suggestions to my co- facilitator as we were doing some joint planning for an event. After we finished, he asked me to reflect on my posture while making my contributions. I realised that I had done it quite hesitantly. I was trying not to be presumptuous with my thoughts, and this had affected my confidence to make a contribution in this particular work situation. It dawned on me that sometimes, because I do not want to appear over-bearing, I deny others the gifts that I have to offer.
In Matthew 5: 13 Jesus challenges us to be the salt of the world. A good meal needs just enough salt. As Christians if we are ‘too much salt’, we can ruin a situation and cause a lot of harm, while if we are ‘too little salt’, we will not make any difference. We might as well not be there. I realised that one of the ways I lose my saltiness is by holding back on what I have to contribute.
Humility involves recognising and boldly using the gifts that God has given us, in the places where he puts us. To be the right amount of salt in team situations, and as an Organisational Development practitioner, I need to work with both humility and confidence. If one overwhelms the other then I lose the beauty and power of who God has created me to be.
To take the opportunities that God is giving me, where do I need to be both confident and humble?
What do I need to strengthen or let go of so that I can be the ‘right amount of salt’?
By Dorothy Grace Stewart
Intercessory prayer does not come naturally for me. My prayers are usually quite self- centered. But one time, whilst assisting
on a job, I believe God uniquely used my intercessory prayer to contribute to his redemptive work in the life of an organization.
In preparation for a two-day intervention I began praying, fasting and trying to listen to God for what might be in store. I had a really lovely half hour walk to work and one morning the word “atrophy,” hit my mind/heart. This was a bit confusing as I have hardly ever used the word. It means wasting away through lack of use. Nevertheless, I wrote it down in my journal and carried on.
About a month later we were at the workshop. The participants were walking back into the conference room carrying some dubious drawings on flip charts. We had asked them to creatively represent what they believed to be the major obstacle to their team’s success. One person unfolded her sheet to reveal the outline of a shriveled lung. She explained that she felt like the team was “atrophying” due to an unwillingness to confront a particular issue and that unless they addressed it, this would be their demise. She dramatically and succinctly put to words a feeling that was resonating throughout the room. She drew what God had whispered to me a month prior.
I spoke with her privately immediately afterwards and showed her my journal. We both were a bit shocked by God’s co-creating with us. She asked me to pray as she felt she was being called to hold the team accountable in the following weeks. Subsequently, this team was able to move in great courage in truly inspirational ways. What extraordinary moments invade our work when we intercede for our work!
What work situations are on your heart to pray for?
By Rick James
We know from our own personal lives that change is fundamentally an emotional process. Any change, even the most positive, has an element of loss and letting go as well as the excitement and hope for the future. Emotions are the vital fuel for change, when things get tough. I read somewhere that 80% of change is emotional, not rational.
Yet, so often we forget this when we walk through the office door. We foolish behave as if brute logic alone was enough. Bill’s story last week from the Mothers’ Union in South Africa illustrated beautifully and powerfully how it is emotion and spirit that bring personal and organisational transformation.
As we look to contribute to positive change at work this week, what could we do to better connect with the inherently emotional and spiritual elements of change?
By Bill Crooks
We were working with 25 Mothers’ Union community development coordinators from across South Africa. As part of our training, my co-facilitator performed a monologue of how it must have felt to be the woman who encountered Jesus at the well (John 4). She was ostracised and rejected by her community. At the end of the drama, there was a long silence before one huge woman (called ‘Tiny’) started weeping for the abused women in her community. After a while, my colleague also told her own story of her poor choice of husband, which led to divorce. Her vulnerability unlocked something. Suddenly participants began to share their own experiences of pain, hurt and sense of rejection. Their own personal stories enabled them to empathise with the women in their communities in a new way. They realised their role as development coordinators was not about managing projects, but acting as ‘wounded healers’. I’ve never been in a workshop so profound.
This week, how might you be a wounded healer?
By Richard Davis
Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind and with all your strength . . . Love your neighbour as yourself (Mark 12 v 30-31)
The quality of the love we offer God, we should also show those around us. Love that is open, sensitive, empathetic, appreciative, intimate, honest, trusting and resilient.
Our clients and colleagues are our neighbours. To serve them as well as we can, means we have to love them. To want the very best for them. To feel a deep sense of responsibility towards them. It’s this sense of responsibility – our capability to respond – that’s the source of the energy we put into loving others.
And in return we also should allow ourselves be loved. After all, it takes two for a relationship to flourish.
This week, what can you do to demonstrate a genuine love and commitment to your colleagues and clients?
By Elaine Vitikainen
A few weeks ago, I was observing a training of 30 church leaders in Cambodia. It was a very hot day as Cambodia was approaching the hottest season. During the lunch break, the participants laid on the tiled floor of the training room. It was a refreshing break, away from the sun, with the air-conditioning cooling the air. When the time came for the training to continue, the participants sat in a circle. In the middle of the circle, one child was still asleep covered in a red blanket. Nobody minded. We went on with the training.
When the facilitator started talking, the girl who was asleep on the floor in the middle of the room woke up and started crying. Then something happened that I did not expect at all. When the child started making noise, the facilitator did not tell the mother to go and take the child away. He did not say, the child was disturbing the training. But instead he said simply, “Oh, I think I was talking too loud.”
This reminded me of the verse on being patient with one another. Ephesians 4:2 says, Be completely humble and gentle; be patient, bearing with one another in love. Technically, I can see he was a good facilitator. But no, he was better. He was facilitating with grace.
Think about how you deal with unexpected disturbances in your work. This week, how can you relate to others with grace?